Horrendous Chinese History
Posted by Cottontimer on 07 Jul 2007 | Tagged as: Our World, Reading
China is an enigma to me. The closest I’ve ever been is Hong Kong and Macau. The more I know about China’s history, however, the more incredible it all seems. Life and Death in Shanghai by Nien Cheng and The Rape of Nanking by Iris Chang (and Chang’s subsequent suicide) shocked and saddened me. And today I read this in Wild Swans by Jung Chang:
One day in 1960, the three-year-old daughter of my aunt Jun-ying’s next-door neighbor in Yibin went missing. A few weeks later the neighbor saw a young girl playing in the street wearing a dress that looked like her daughter’s. She went up and examined it: it had a mark which identified it as her daughter’s. She reported this to the police. It turned out that the parents of the young girl were selling wind-dried meat. They had abducted and murdered a number of babies and sold them as rabbit meat at exorbitant prices. The couple were executed and the case was hushed up, but it was widely known that baby killing did go on at the time.
For every day that I’m alive, I should be grateful to be who I am, where I am, and when I am.
Related Posts:
Chinese Au Pairs...
Types of Chinese in America...
Stephen, The Chinese Boy...
The Chinese Way...
Acronyms Not For Children’s Ears...
Blogging in China...
Positive Sentiments on Blogging...
If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it's probably in moderation. I will approve it as soon as I can! Thanks for your patience.




I was deeply moved by Wild Swans when I read it; it was the only Chinese history I knew for an extremely long time, and not until I did a course on Chinese art in the 20th century did I get any proper grip on what happened. This is why I studied art history, we get to cover pretty much the whole of Chinese history and culture at least briefly!
(it’s not likely that you’ll have any time to read it, but the book which really “shook me up” was Julia Andrew’s “Painters and Politics in the People’s Republic of China”)
However, Jung Chang’s credibility was harmed so badly by her MAO biography that I can’t really take her words so seriously as I did at the time. MAO is a jumble of tales passed on “based on the author’s memory of a conversation she had with a person who wishes to remain anonymous” — not academic at all, and yet not written in the “popular science” style which makes reading agreable to the non-academic.
An example of the “easy-reading” which I read recently was The Kitchen God’s Wife, by Amy Tan. It was slow going at first as I didn’t really identify with the American/Chinese 華僑 crisis, but it became far more interesting once it concentrated on the mother’s secret past. I learnt a lot about the way the war with the Japanese had unfolded, and also about the traditional silence and submissiveness of Chinese women, which is something I think about a lot. If I were to go back to university, I’d be extremely keen to research the cultural attitudes of women here in Taiwan… they really are very mysterious.
Ramble ramble… by now you know that this is what you can expect from me when you mention China!
Rosie, You have more experience than I do when it comes to China! Wild Swans was an incredible read. I think I finished it in a week which isn’t bad for 500 pages!
Hsien, I had the privilege of working six weeks in China. I grew to love the people there with whom I had the privilege of working. Wild Swans gives insights into China that I had no idea of. I read it when I returned and because I did that, I grew to understand the people even more. The newspapers do not give us a true picture of the people in China. We only hear about leaders.
It’s hard to know exactly what the people are like in countries like China when they have one face for foreigners and one face for locals. A bit frightening….
i like the Good Earth and another book you might want to read is Mao’s Last Dancer by Li CunXin - it gave an insight to what it was like during communism. i am Chinese by heritage but Malaysian and reading these books gave me an insight. i am now living in China for short periods and have discovered that i am a world apart although i am Chinese
Thanks for the recommendations! I read The Good Earth years ago but haven’t heard of Mao’s Last Dancer. I don’t know how I’ll feel if I ever live in China. It would certainly be an eye-opening experience.
Hi Hsien
There’s a really interesting thread amongst Chinese mothers on http://www.mumsnet.com - you’ll pick up alot of info and experiences both here and abroad on there.
Kindest Regards
Andrea
(P.S. was sorry to see you go from the Play Library but enjoying the DNA site when I have the chance.
Hi Andrea,
How nice to hear from you again! Please stay in touch.