Boys Should Go First
Posted by Cottontimer on 05 Jul 2007 | Tagged as: Parenting, Stephen
Seeing things from a boy’s point of view is not easy for a mother who identifies herself as a feminist and women’s rights supporter. Like many women, I thought (and hoped) that I would have a daughter who I would teach to conquer the world. But then I gave birth to a boy and it’s probably for the better.
If I’d had a daughter, I might have become complacent because I would assume that I understood what she was going through. I would have treated her as an extension of myself which wouldn’t have been fair. Having a boy means I work harder at understanding things from his point of view. I read more, I research more, I think more about his experiences and what he will have to go through as he grows into a man.
Mike Miller over at Be A Good Dad points to statistics from The Boys Project that would worry any parent of a boy. They show that on average, boys are not doing better in our current girl-supporting culture and in fact, many are doing worse.* The mission of The Boys Project is “to accomplish for young men what the Girls Project so successfully accomplished for young women— to increase academic skills, to increase college success, and to develop the confidence, drive, and determination to contribute to American society.” Stephen may be catching on to this disparity a bit precociously.
Lately in school, he isn’t always very cooperative and protests more than what the teachers would like. His teacher told me that his new favorite phrase is “That’s not fair!” and one day, when she let the girls get in line first, he shouted, “Awww. That’s not fair!” Now of course I’m pretty sure she doesn’t always let the girls go first, but clearly Stephen has the makings of an activist and protestor.
Tony Woodlief said in the Wall Street Journal last month:
…I can’t shake the sense that boys are supposed to become manly. Rather than neutering their aggression, confidence and desire for danger, we should channel these instincts into honor, gentlemanliness and courage. Instead of inculcating timidity in our sons, it seems wiser to train them to face down bullies, which by necessity means teaching them how to throw a good uppercut. In his book “Manliness,” Harvey Mansfield writes that a person manifesting this quality “not only knows what justice requires, but he acts on his knowledge, making and executing the decision that the rest of us trembled even to define.” You can’t build a civilization and defend it against barbarians, fascists and playground bullies, in other words, with a nation of Phil Donahues.
I totally buy this argument and in fact I did literally as well when I purchased a copy of Woodlief’s pamphlet: Raising Wild Boys Into Men.
I can deal with wild. In fact, I’m pretty wild myself and I think it’s served me well.
*Of course we should continue to encourage girls but should not forget about the boys!
Related Posts:
Obi-Wan’s New Talent...
Pregnant Women with Girls are Batty...
Google Trends for Boys, Girls, Women, Men...
Teenage Boys Are Scary...
Put Away the Lavender...
Snoop Dogg is Inappropriate...
Delaying Nursery School...
If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it's probably in moderation. I will approve it as soon as I can! Thanks for your patience.
9 Comments
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.




I think that Woodlief chap has got it right. That’s how I’d like to raise my (future) sons. It’s not so much about taming wild boys (which hints of emasculation somehow), but about channeling all their “cowboy genes” (as Woodlief calls it) into building positive qualities. Honour, bravery, strength, fortitude, etc are percepts that resonate with most males and can serve as great character building blocks if cultivated and encouraged from a young age methinks.
Sadly though, wild boys today are increasingly encouraged to become mild boys instead with our modern-day fascination with SNAGs, metrosexuals and other namby-pambies! *bleah*
So when are we going to see your manly theories in action?
I agree! I think in trying to compensate for past grievances, our balance in raising kids is all out of whack. Girls and boys should be treated equally and boys need just as much developmental attention as girls. It’s as if we are in a time warp of reverse sexism. You even see it in the workplace nowadays where women are sometimes coddled and nurtured (by other women) and men are expected (ignored) to make it on their own. Or even when it comes to childcare where women are expected to be the primary caregivers given allowances but the men are expected to just go right back to work the very next week if not the very next day! I hope our generation is able to change things for the better so that I don’t hear Stephen declare “that’s not fair” 20+ years from now.
*sigh* The more things change, the more they stay the same!
Your first paragraph could have been written by me! When Niels was a baby his energy brought smiles and “awws” and “how old is he?” Now that he’s 5 he gets disapproving looks while people coo at Stefan and ask how old he is without even acknowledging Niels. It makes me sad for him.
I have to admit that before I had kids, I didn’t really think they were cute after the toddler stage. Now, of course, I appreciate the older ones a lot more!
ooo hot button topic.
One would think in our age of enlightenment, that we’d have figured out that all children are precious individuals who deserve equal treatment across the board. period.
It’s horribly frustrating sometimes to be raising all boys. But on the other hand, when my kids are just being kids, running and wiggly and loud, people generally just think “oh that’s boys”; whereas if I had daughters I would be getting disapproving *looks*. Despite the fact that a lot of girls love to run and leap and be wiggly.
Who are these people who would look askance at girls running free??? I’d like to smack them.
[...] have been, of course, a few bumps along the road. Being one of the youngest in class and a singleton as well, it’s been a [...]