Are you my sister or my daughter?
Posted by Cottontimer on 03 Jul 2007 | Tagged as: Thoughts
|
Although this story makes me feel uncomfortable, there have been plenty of cases where orphaned children are brought up by their older siblings who act as surrogate parents. And likewise, plenty of cases where grandparents bring up their grandchildren effectively acting as their parents. Sometimes the children are even deceived into believing their mothers are their sisters. The family relationship quagmire is nothing new although this use if IVF technology is definitely unusual.
Related Posts:
Top Idiots: Enemas...
You Don’t Have to Like It...
Family History...
PSA: Hamsters Can Make You Sick...
Childhood Friendships...
Bedtime...
Big Brother Knows Best...
If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it's probably in moderation. I will approve it as soon as I can! Thanks for your patience.




One of my nieces is legally adopted by my dad, so we tease her that she is actually her own aunt (yeah, my dad’s humor isn’t the best, haha), or that she’s no longer our neice, she’s our sister. Muddled family relationships are nothing new, and most people are able to sort it out. And a far more uncomfortable situation is girls bearing children by their father–their offspring would also technically be their half-siblings. ‘genealogical bewilderment’ sounds like the sort of phrase that is meant to be important but really doesn’t mean much. Family doesn’t have to be sorted into neat little boxes.
Hi Donna!
I’m guessing that everyone has mixed-up family relationships somewhere in the family tree and most probably within recent generations. And I agree about the taboos invoked by a daughter using father’s sperm although if it’s IVF-related, it wouldn’t be much different than this situation. AHHH, societal rules are so complicated. The ethicists are having a field day!